Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

BtVS Rewatch!! - organisation/review sign up

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • BtVS Rewatch!! - organisation/review sign up

    OK, so I'm trying to get the ball rolling to start the rewatch, if we don't get enough interest in organising this way we'll have to have a rethink.


    Below is a list of all the episodes for S1. If you are happy to take on providing the initial post for an episode then please put your name beside one or two (in the first instance). It can be a full review or just brief thoughts, the idea is just to have a prompting post for each episode. There is also a list to add in any topic suggestions/ideas you might have to try and draw out some different discussions/debates.

    There is of course always the risk of real life disruptions/interruptions. I'd suggest if an episode review goes over a couple of days late that it becomes 'open' for anyone to pop on some initial thoughts to keep things moving.

    If everyone can also vote on whether they would prefer every three days or two set days a week to have watched the eps by that would be helpful (the previous poll showed the vast majority would prefer to watch two episodes per week).

    -------------------------


    **Pop your name next to 1 or 2 unclaimed episodes you're happy to provide the first review of**

    Allocation is on a first come, first served basis.

    1.01 - Welcome to the Hellmouth -
    1.02 - The Harvest -
    1.03 - Witch -
    1.04 - Teacher's Pet -
    1.05 - Never Kill a Boy on the First Date -
    1.06 - The Pack -
    1.07 - Angel -
    1.08 - I, Robot... You, Jane -
    1.09 - The Puppet Show -
    1.10 - Nightmares -
    1.11 - Out of Mind, Out of Sight -
    1.12 - Prophecy Girl -


    **Any general topic ideas**
    • Favourite character moment
    • Best subliminal message
    • Weakest element of episode (script/set/wardrobe/plot etc)
    20
    for new episodes to be watched every three days?
    20.00%
    4
    to have two set days a week to have watched the episodes by?
    80.00%
    16

  • #2
    Thanks for getting the ball rolling on this, Stoney. I'd like to cover The Harvest and I Robot You Jane.

    1.01 - Welcome to the Hellmouth -
    1.02 - The Harvest - Dipstick
    1.03 - Witch -
    1.04 - Teacher's Pet -
    1.05 - Never Kill a Boy on the First Date -
    1.06 - The Pack -
    1.07 - Angel -
    1.08 - I, Robot... You, Jane - Dipstick
    1.09 - The Puppet Show -
    1.10 - Nightmares -
    1.11 - Out of Mind, Out of Sight -
    1.12 - Prophecy Girl -


    **Any general topic ideas**

    Favourite character moment
    Best subliminal message
    Weakest element of episode (script/set/wardrobe/plot etc)

    Comment


    • #3
      1.01 - Welcome to the Hellmouth -
      1.02 - The Harvest - Dipstick
      1.03 - Witch -
      1.04 - Teacher's Pet -
      1.05 - Never Kill a Boy on the First Date - Stoney
      1.06 - The Pack -
      1.07 - Angel -
      1.08 - I, Robot... You, Jane - Dipstick
      1.09 - The Puppet Show -
      1.10 - Nightmares - Stoney
      1.11 - Out of Mind, Out of Sight -
      1.12 - Prophecy Girl -


      **Any general topic ideas**

      Favourite character moment
      Best subliminal message
      Weakest element of episode (script/set/wardrobe/plot etc)

      Comment


      • #4
        Count me in!!! Is it okay to cover one episode? I'd be so scared about RL taking over and I don't wanna let anyone down.

        1.01 - Welcome to the Hellmouth -
        1.02 - The Harvest - Dipstick
        1.03 - Witch -
        1.04 - Teacher's Pet - Sosa Lola
        1.05 - Never Kill a Boy on the First Date - Stoney
        1.06 - The Pack -
        1.07 - Angel -
        1.08 - I, Robot... You, Jane - Dipstick
        1.09 - The Puppet Show -
        1.10 - Nightmares - Stoney
        1.11 - Out of Mind, Out of Sight -
        1.12 - Prophecy Girl -


        How about "new discoveries" for general topic ideas? Something you've noticed for the first time. It'll be exciting to discuss something we never discussed before.
        Made by Trickyboxes
        Halfrek gives Spike the curse that will change his entire life. Teenage Dirtbag

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by Sosa lola View Post
          Count me in!!! Is it okay to cover one episode? I'd be so scared about RL taking over and I don't wanna let anyone down.
          Of course, any contribution will be great. I've popped your topic idea on with the others below, I really like that one.

          _____

          1.01 - Welcome to the Hellmouth -
          1.02 - The Harvest - Dipstick
          1.03 - Witch -
          1.04 - Teacher's Pet - Sosa Lola
          1.05 - Never Kill a Boy on the First Date - Stoney
          1.06 - The Pack -
          1.07 - Angel -
          1.08 - I, Robot... You, Jane - Dipstick
          1.09 - The Puppet Show -
          1.10 - Nightmares - Stoney
          1.11 - Out of Mind, Out of Sight -
          1.12 - Prophecy Girl -


          **Add in any general topic ideas**

          Favourite character moment
          Best subliminal message
          Weakest element of episode (script/set/wardrobe/plot etc)
          Something you've noticed for the first time.

          Comment


          • #6
            Yeah, okay, I can say a few things about The Pack.

            Comment


            • #7
              Great stuff Max.

              _____

              1.01 - Welcome to the Hellmouth -
              1.02 - The Harvest - Dipstick
              1.03 - Witch -
              1.04 - Teacher's Pet - Sosa Lola
              1.05 - Never Kill a Boy on the First Date - Stoney
              1.06 - The Pack - Local Max
              1.07 - Angel -
              1.08 - I, Robot... You, Jane - Dipstick
              1.09 - The Puppet Show -
              1.10 - Nightmares - Stoney
              1.11 - Out of Mind, Out of Sight -
              1.12 - Prophecy Girl -


              **Add in any general topic ideas**

              Favourite character moment
              Best subliminal message
              Weakest element of episode (script/set/wardrobe/plot etc)
              Something you've noticed for the first time.

              Comment


              • #8
                I guess I can do IRYJ too.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Local_Max, I claimed IRYJ already. However, I'm not that attached to covering that ep. I'd be happy to cover Out of Mind, Out of Sight instead and you can take IRYJ.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Oh, I missed that! silly me. No, you can take that. I might want to only cover one ep anyway.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Ooh... so many good ones to choose from!


                      1.01 - Welcome to the Hellmouth -
                      1.02 - The Harvest - Dipstick
                      1.03 - Witch -
                      1.04 - Teacher's Pet - Sosa Lola
                      1.05 - Never Kill a Boy on the First Date - Stoney
                      1.06 - The Pack - Local Max
                      1.07 - Angel -
                      1.08 - I, Robot... You, Jane - Dipstick
                      1.09 - The Puppet Show - Maggie
                      1.10 - Nightmares - Stoney
                      1.11 - Out of Mind, Out of Sight -
                      1.12 - Prophecy Girl - Maggie


                      **Add in any general topic ideas**

                      Favourite character moment
                      Best subliminal message
                      Weakest element of episode (script/set/wardrobe/plot etc)
                      Something you've noticed for the first time.[/QUOTE]
                      sigpic
                      "I don't want to be this good-looking and athletic. We all have crosses to bear." Banner Credit: Vampmogs

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by Local Maximum View Post
                        Oh, I missed that! silly me. No, you can take that. I might want to only cover one ep anyway.
                        OK- but only if you want to just cover one ep. I'm very happy to take OOM,OOS instead of IRYJ.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          I can try and cover Angel if nobody else wants to?

                          1.01 - Welcome to the Hellmouth -
                          1.02 - The Harvest - Dipstick
                          1.03 - Witch -
                          1.04 - Teacher's Pet - Sosa Lola
                          1.05 - Never Kill a Boy on the First Date - Stoney
                          1.06 - The Pack - Local Max
                          1.07 - Angel - vampmogs
                          1.08 - I, Robot... You, Jane - Dipstick
                          1.09 - The Puppet Show - Maggie
                          1.10 - Nightmares - Stoney
                          1.11 - Out of Mind, Out of Sight -
                          1.12 - Prophecy Girl - Maggie
                          Last edited by vampmogs; 09-03-14, 12:19 AM.
                          "The earth is doomed!" - Banner by Nina

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            This is great we are filling up quickly, just three left.

                            The current majority is leaning towards picking two set days a week. I presume an evenish spacing would be preferable, so would one weekend and one mid-week suit most people? I won't even try to pretend to get my head around the different time zones (), but would assume we could make it fit either Sat/Wed or Sun/Thu, depending on where you are??


                            ----

                            1.01 - Welcome to the Hellmouth -
                            1.02 - The Harvest - Dipstick
                            1.03 - Witch -
                            1.04 - Teacher's Pet - Sosa Lola
                            1.05 - Never Kill a Boy on the First Date - Stoney
                            1.06 - The Pack - Local Max
                            1.07 - Angel - vampmogs
                            1.08 - I, Robot... You, Jane - Dipstick
                            1.09 - The Puppet Show - Maggie
                            1.10 - Nightmares - Stoney
                            1.11 - Out of Mind, Out of Sight -
                            1.12 - Prophecy Girl - Maggie


                            **Add in any general topic ideas**

                            Favourite character moment
                            Best subliminal message
                            Weakest element of episode (script/set/wardrobe/plot etc)
                            Something you've noticed for the first time.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              I guess I'll also be willing to do do Out of Mind, Out of Sight as long as people aren't anticipating any groundbreaking insights

                              So that just leaves us with WttH and Witch

                              1.01 - Welcome to the Hellmouth -
                              1.02 - The Harvest - Dipstick
                              1.03 - Witch -
                              1.04 - Teacher's Pet - Sosa Lola
                              1.05 - Never Kill a Boy on the First Date - Stoney
                              1.06 - The Pack - Local Max
                              1.07 - Angel - vampmogs
                              1.08 - I, Robot... You, Jane - Dipstick
                              1.09 - The Puppet Show - Maggie
                              1.10 - Nightmares - Stoney
                              1.11 - Out of Mind, Out of Sight - vampmogs
                              1.12 - Prophecy Girl - Maggie


                              **Add in any general topic ideas**

                              Favourite character moment
                              Best subliminal message
                              Weakest element of episode (script/set/wardrobe/plot etc)
                              Something you've noticed for the first time.
                              "The earth is doomed!" - Banner by Nina

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X