Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Best episode and season of Buffy and Angel [2]

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Best episode and season of Buffy and Angel [2]

    We haven't had a "best episode" game in a while (not best episode by writer, just best episode in general). We'll start with Buffy, then when we finish we'll have a best season game. Then the same with Angel.

    I'm not sure if we should count the comics seasons with the others, or only add that part of the game later. What say you?

    BTW, we could also have a best Firefly episode game and best Dollhouse episode game. Is anyone up for that?

    You know the rules: you can vote again only after 3 other people have voted.

    Best episode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer

    Season 1

    + Prophecy Girl
    - Teacher's Pet

    Welcome to the Hellmouth 5
    The Harvest 5
    Witch 5
    Teacher's Pet 4
    Never Kill a Boy on the First Date 5
    The Pack 5
    Angel 5
    I, Robot...You Jane 5
    The Puppet Show 5
    Nightmares 5
    Out of Mind, Out of Sight 5
    Prophecy Girl 6

    Reset at:
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    12.

    Winners:
    Buffy season 1:
    Buffy season 2:
    Buffy season 3:
    Buffy season 4:
    Buffy season 5:
    Buffy season 6:
    Buffy season 7:
    Angel season 1:
    Angel season 2:
    Angel season 3:
    Angel season 4:
    Angel season 5:
    Buffy season 8:
    Buffy season 9:
    Angel & Faith:

    Best season:
    You keep waiting for the dust to settle and then you realize it; the dust is your life going on. If happy comes along - that weird unbearable delight that's actual happy - I think you have to grab it while you can. You take what you can get, 'cause it's here, and then...gone.

  • #2
    The original thread had over 1000 posts which can cause the forum to slow and not function well. The forum hasnt worked well today, so I am closing threads with over 1000 pots. I copied the last page of posts from the original thread. If anthing else is needed to transition this thread, please let me know.

    Original thread here.

    When someone notices this thread to be over 900 posts, please start a new one. Or contact a mod to make a new thread if you need any posts copied. Thanks!

    Lydia made the punch!

    Comment


    • #3
      + The Trial
      - Dead End

      Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been - 9
      Dear Boy - 8
      Darla - 10
      The Trial - 9
      Reunion - 7
      Redefinition - 7
      Reprise - 8
      Epiphany - 5
      Dead End - 3
      Belonging - 10



      Reset Points At:
      15
      9
      5

      Eliminated:
      22. Through the Looking Glass
      21. The Shroud of Rahmon
      20. First Impressions
      19. Judgment
      18. Blood Money
      17. Happy Anniversary
      16. The Thin Dead Line
      15. There's No Place Like Plrtz Glrb
      14. Untouched
      13. Disharmony
      12. Guise Will Be Guise
      11. Over the Rainbow

      Winners:
      Buffy season 1: Prophecy Girl
      Buffy season 2: Becoming, part 2
      Buffy season 3: The Wish
      Buffy season 4: Something Blue
      Buffy season 5: Intervention
      Buffy season 6: Dead Things
      Buffy season 7: Conversations with Dead People
      Angel season 1: The Prodigal
      Angel season 2:
      Angel season 3:
      Angel season 4:
      Angel season 5:
      Buffy season 8:
      Buffy season 9:
      Angel & Faith:
      You keep waiting for the dust to settle and then you realize it; the dust is your life going on. If happy comes along - that weird unbearable delight that's actual happy - I think you have to grab it while you can. You take what you can get, 'cause it's here, and then...gone.

      Comment


      • #4
        + The Trial
        - Are you now

        Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been - 8
        Dear Boy - 8
        Darla - 10
        The Trial - 10
        Reunion - 7
        Redefinition - 7
        Reprise - 8
        Epiphany - 5
        Dead End - 3
        Belonging - 10



        Reset Points At:
        15
        9
        5

        Eliminated:
        22. Through the Looking Glass
        21. The Shroud of Rahmon
        20. First Impressions
        19. Judgment
        18. Blood Money
        17. Happy Anniversary
        16. The Thin Dead Line
        15. There's No Place Like Plrtz Glrb
        14. Untouched
        13. Disharmony
        12. Guise Will Be Guise
        11. Over the Rainbow

        Winners:
        Buffy season 1: Prophecy Girl
        Buffy season 2: Becoming, part 2
        Buffy season 3: The Wish
        Buffy season 4: Something Blue
        Buffy season 5: Intervention
        Buffy season 6: Dead Things
        Buffy season 7: Conversations with Dead People
        Angel season 1: The Prodigal
        Angel season 2:
        Angel season 3:
        Angel season 4:
        Angel season 5:
        Buffy season 8:
        Buffy season 9:
        Angel & Faith:
        sigpic
        maked by plamivasi

        Comment


        • #5
          Epiphany +
          Dead End -

          Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been - 8
          Dear Boy - 8
          Darla - 10
          The Trial - 10
          Reunion - 7
          Redefinition - 7
          Reprise - 8
          Epiphany - 6
          Dead End - 2
          Belonging - 10



          Reset Points At:
          15
          9
          5

          Eliminated:
          22. Through the Looking Glass
          21. The Shroud of Rahmon
          20. First Impressions
          19. Judgment
          18. Blood Money
          17. Happy Anniversary
          16. The Thin Dead Line
          15. There's No Place Like Plrtz Glrb
          14. Untouched
          13. Disharmony
          12. Guise Will Be Guise
          11. Over the Rainbow

          Winners:
          Buffy season 1: Prophecy Girl
          Buffy season 2: Becoming, part 2
          Buffy season 3: The Wish
          Buffy season 4: Something Blue
          Buffy season 5: Intervention
          Buffy season 6: Dead Things
          Buffy season 7: Conversations with Dead People
          Angel season 1: The Prodigal
          Angel season 2:
          Angel season 3:
          Angel season 4:
          Angel season 5:
          Buffy season 8:
          Buffy season 9:
          Angel & Faith:

          Comment


          • #6
            Ach, people obviously want Dead End gone over the others and I am not going to fight majority, it has got around where I expected it to. It is only for how much I love that one scene that I was voting for it so I'm happy to step down and let it go to get to reset (particularly as the Alien 4 esque part was pants ).


            + Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
            - Epiphany


            Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been - 9
            Dear Boy - 8
            Darla - 10
            The Trial - 10
            Reunion - 7
            Redefinition - 7
            Reprise - 8
            Epiphany - 5
            Dead End - 2
            Belonging - 10



            Reset Points At:
            15
            9
            5

            Eliminated:
            22. Through the Looking Glass
            21. The Shroud of Rahmon
            20. First Impressions
            19. Judgment
            18. Blood Money
            17. Happy Anniversary
            16. The Thin Dead Line
            15. There's No Place Like Plrtz Glrb
            14. Untouched
            13. Disharmony
            12. Guise Will Be Guise
            11. Over the Rainbow

            Winners:
            Buffy season 1: Prophecy Girl
            Buffy season 2: Becoming, part 2
            Buffy season 3: The Wish
            Buffy season 4: Something Blue
            Buffy season 5: Intervention
            Buffy season 6: Dead Things
            Buffy season 7: Conversations with Dead People
            Angel season 1: The Prodigal
            Angel season 2:
            Angel season 3:
            Angel season 4:
            Angel season 5:
            Buffy season 8:
            Buffy season 9:
            Angel & Faith:

            Comment


            • #7
              + Reunion
              - Dead End - just 1 point away from the reset!

              Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been - 9
              Dear Boy - 8
              Darla - 10
              The Trial - 10
              Reunion - 8
              Redefinition - 7
              Reprise - 8
              Epiphany - 5
              Dead End - 1
              Belonging - 10



              Reset Points At:
              15
              9
              5

              Eliminated:
              22. Through the Looking Glass
              21. The Shroud of Rahmon
              20. First Impressions
              19. Judgment
              18. Blood Money
              17. Happy Anniversary
              16. The Thin Dead Line
              15. There's No Place Like Plrtz Glrb
              14. Untouched
              13. Disharmony
              12. Guise Will Be Guise
              11. Over the Rainbow

              Winners:
              Buffy season 1: Prophecy Girl
              Buffy season 2: Becoming, part 2
              Buffy season 3: The Wish
              Buffy season 4: Something Blue
              Buffy season 5: Intervention
              Buffy season 6: Dead Things
              Buffy season 7: Conversations with Dead People
              Angel season 1: The Prodigal
              Angel season 2:
              Angel season 3:
              Angel season 4:
              Angel season 5:
              Buffy season 8:
              Buffy season 9:
              Angel & Faith:
              You keep waiting for the dust to settle and then you realize it; the dust is your life going on. If happy comes along - that weird unbearable delight that's actual happy - I think you have to grab it while you can. You take what you can get, 'cause it's here, and then...gone.

              Comment


              • #8
                Mwahahaha!

                + Dead End
                - Epiphany

                Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been - 9
                Dear Boy - 8
                Darla - 10
                The Trial - 10
                Reunion - 8
                Redefinition - 7
                Reprise - 8
                Epiphany - 4
                Dead End - 2
                Belonging - 10



                Reset Points At:
                15
                9
                5

                Eliminated:
                22. Through the Looking Glass
                21. The Shroud of Rahmon
                20. First Impressions
                19. Judgment
                18. Blood Money
                17. Happy Anniversary
                16. The Thin Dead Line
                15. There's No Place Like Plrtz Glrb
                14. Untouched
                13. Disharmony
                12. Guise Will Be Guise
                11. Over the Rainbow

                Winners:
                Buffy season 1: Prophecy Girl
                Buffy season 2: Becoming, part 2
                Buffy season 3: The Wish
                Buffy season 4: Something Blue
                Buffy season 5: Intervention
                Buffy season 6: Dead Things
                Buffy season 7: Conversations with Dead People
                Angel season 1: The Prodigal
                Angel season 2:
                Angel season 3:
                Angel season 4:
                Angel season 5:
                Buffy season 8:
                Buffy season 9:
                Angel & Faith:
                sigpic

                Comment


                • #9
                  Dead End -
                  Epiphany +

                  Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been - 9
                  Dear Boy - 8
                  Darla - 10
                  The Trial - 10
                  Reunion - 8
                  Redefinition - 7
                  Reprise - 8
                  Epiphany - 5
                  Dead End - 1
                  Belonging - 10



                  Reset Points At:
                  15
                  9
                  5

                  Eliminated:
                  22. Through the Looking Glass
                  21. The Shroud of Rahmon
                  20. First Impressions
                  19. Judgment
                  18. Blood Money
                  17. Happy Anniversary
                  16. The Thin Dead Line
                  15. There's No Place Like Plrtz Glrb
                  14. Untouched
                  13. Disharmony
                  12. Guise Will Be Guise
                  11. Over the Rainbow

                  Winners:
                  Buffy season 1: Prophecy Girl
                  Buffy season 2: Becoming, part 2
                  Buffy season 3: The Wish
                  Buffy season 4: Something Blue
                  Buffy season 5: Intervention
                  Buffy season 6: Dead Things
                  Buffy season 7: Conversations with Dead People
                  Angel season 1: The Prodigal
                  Angel season 2:
                  Angel season 3:
                  Angel season 4:
                  Angel season 5:
                  Buffy season 8:
                  Buffy season 9:
                  Angel & Faith:

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    - Are you now
                    + Darla

                    Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been - 8
                    Dear Boy - 8
                    Darla - 11
                    The Trial - 10
                    Reunion - 8
                    Redefinition - 7
                    Reprise - 8
                    Epiphany - 5
                    Dead End - 1
                    Belonging - 10



                    Reset Points At:
                    15
                    9
                    5

                    Eliminated:
                    22. Through the Looking Glass
                    21. The Shroud of Rahmon
                    20. First Impressions
                    19. Judgment
                    18. Blood Money
                    17. Happy Anniversary
                    16. The Thin Dead Line
                    15. There's No Place Like Plrtz Glrb
                    14. Untouched
                    13. Disharmony
                    12. Guise Will Be Guise
                    11. Over the Rainbow

                    Winners:
                    Buffy season 1: Prophecy Girl
                    Buffy season 2: Becoming, part 2
                    Buffy season 3: The Wish
                    Buffy season 4: Something Blue
                    Buffy season 5: Intervention
                    Buffy season 6: Dead Things
                    Buffy season 7: Conversations with Dead People
                    Angel season 1: The Prodigal
                    Angel season 2:
                    Angel season 3:
                    Angel season 4:
                    Angel season 5:
                    Buffy season 8:
                    Buffy season 9:
                    Angel & Faith:
                    sigpic
                    maked by plamivasi

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      _Buffy_ I'm curious, can you explain to me why you consider Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been the worst episode left? I think it's one of the best episodes in the whole Buffyverse and I'm just curious why you don't like it all that much.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        + Are YOu Now
                        - Dead End *dusted* RESET

                        Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been - 6
                        Dear Boy - 5
                        Darla - 5
                        The Trial - 5
                        Reunion - 5
                        Redefinition - 5
                        Reprise - 5
                        Epiphany - 5
                        Belonging - 5



                        Reset Points At:
                        15
                        9
                        5

                        Eliminated:
                        22. Through the Looking Glass
                        21. The Shroud of Rahmon
                        20. First Impressions
                        19. Judgment
                        18. Blood Money
                        17. Happy Anniversary
                        16. The Thin Dead Line
                        15. There's No Place Like Plrtz Glrb
                        14. Untouched
                        13. Disharmony
                        12. Guise Will Be Guise
                        11. Over the Rainbow
                        10. Dead End

                        Winners:
                        Buffy season 1: Prophecy Girl
                        Buffy season 2: Becoming, part 2
                        Buffy season 3: The Wish
                        Buffy season 4: Something Blue
                        Buffy season 5: Intervention
                        Buffy season 6: Dead Things
                        Buffy season 7: Conversations with Dead People
                        Angel season 1: The Prodigal
                        Angel season 2:
                        Angel season 3:
                        Angel season 4:
                        Angel season 5:
                        Buffy season 8:
                        Buffy season 9:
                        Angel & Faith:
                        You keep waiting for the dust to settle and then you realize it; the dust is your life going on. If happy comes along - that weird unbearable delight that's actual happy - I think you have to grab it while you can. You take what you can get, 'cause it's here, and then...gone.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by Nina View Post
                          _Buffy_ I'm curious, can you explain to me why you consider Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been the worst episode left?
                          I wondered too, I'm not sure where I'd place it in the whole verse but I'd put it in the top five of this season.


                          + Belonging
                          - Redefinition

                          Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been - 6
                          Dear Boy - 5
                          Darla - 5
                          The Trial - 5
                          Reunion - 5
                          Redefinition - 4
                          Reprise - 5
                          Epiphany - 5
                          Belonging - 6



                          Reset Points At:
                          15
                          9
                          5

                          Eliminated:
                          22. Through the Looking Glass
                          21. The Shroud of Rahmon
                          20. First Impressions
                          19. Judgment
                          18. Blood Money
                          17. Happy Anniversary
                          16. The Thin Dead Line
                          15. There's No Place Like Plrtz Glrb
                          14. Untouched
                          13. Disharmony
                          12. Guise Will Be Guise
                          11. Over the Rainbow
                          10. Dead End

                          Winners:
                          Buffy season 1: Prophecy Girl
                          Buffy season 2: Becoming, part 2
                          Buffy season 3: The Wish
                          Buffy season 4: Something Blue
                          Buffy season 5: Intervention
                          Buffy season 6: Dead Things
                          Buffy season 7: Conversations with Dead People
                          Angel season 1: The Prodigal
                          Angel season 2:
                          Angel season 3:
                          Angel season 4:
                          Angel season 5:
                          Buffy season 8:
                          Buffy season 9:
                          Angel & Faith:

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            - Belonging
                            + Reprise

                            Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been - 6
                            Dear Boy - 5
                            Darla - 5
                            The Trial - 5
                            Reunion - 5
                            Redefinition - 4
                            Reprise - 6
                            Epiphany - 5
                            Belonging - 5



                            Reset Points At:
                            15
                            9
                            5

                            Eliminated:
                            22. Through the Looking Glass
                            21. The Shroud of Rahmon
                            20. First Impressions
                            19. Judgment
                            18. Blood Money
                            17. Happy Anniversary
                            16. The Thin Dead Line
                            15. There's No Place Like Plrtz Glrb
                            14. Untouched
                            13. Disharmony
                            12. Guise Will Be Guise
                            11. Over the Rainbow
                            10. Dead End

                            Winners:
                            Buffy season 1: Prophecy Girl
                            Buffy season 2: Becoming, part 2
                            Buffy season 3: The Wish
                            Buffy season 4: Something Blue
                            Buffy season 5: Intervention
                            Buffy season 6: Dead Things
                            Buffy season 7: Conversations with Dead People
                            Angel season 1: The Prodigal
                            Angel season 2:
                            Angel season 3:
                            Angel season 4:
                            Angel season 5:
                            Buffy season 8:
                            Buffy season 9:
                            Angel & Faith:

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              - Aro you now
                              + Dear boy

                              Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been - 5
                              Dear Boy - 4
                              Darla - 5
                              The Trial - 5
                              Reunion - 5
                              Redefinition - 4
                              Reprise - 6
                              Epiphany - 5
                              Belonging - 5



                              Reset Points At:
                              15
                              9
                              5

                              Eliminated:
                              22. Through the Looking Glass
                              21. The Shroud of Rahmon
                              20. First Impressions
                              19. Judgment
                              18. Blood Money
                              17. Happy Anniversary
                              16. The Thin Dead Line
                              15. There's No Place Like Plrtz Glrb
                              14. Untouched
                              13. Disharmony
                              12. Guise Will Be Guise
                              11. Over the Rainbow
                              10. Dead End

                              Winners:
                              Buffy season 1: Prophecy Girl
                              Buffy season 2: Becoming, part 2
                              Buffy season 3: The Wish
                              Buffy season 4: Something Blue
                              Buffy season 5: Intervention
                              Buffy season 6: Dead Things
                              Buffy season 7: Conversations with Dead People
                              Angel season 1: The Prodigal
                              Angel season 2:
                              Angel season 3:
                              Angel season 4:
                              Angel season 5:
                              Buffy season 8:
                              Buffy season 9:
                              Angel & Faith:
                              sigpic
                              maked by plamivasi

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X