Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Best Supernatural Episode Tournament

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • The Best Supernatural Episode Tournament

    This is the replacement post for Blaster Boy's original opening post for this game, so I will be able to modify the overview post as the new moderator for this game thread. For instructions on how to play this game, please read the second post.

    Season 1
    Pilot - Eliminated Round 7
    Wendigo - Eliminated Round 3 (Tie)
    Dead in the Water - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)
    Phantom Traveler - Eliminated Round 10 (Tie)
    Bloody Mary - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)
    Skin - Eliminated Round 6
    Hook Man - Eliminated Round 1
    Bugs - Eliminated Round 2
    Home - Eliminated Round 8
    Asylum - Eliminated Round 9 (Tie)
    Scarecrow - Eliminated Round 14 - #3
    Faith - Eliminated Round 15 - #2

    Route 666 - Eliminated Round 3 (Tie)
    Nightmare - Eliminated Round 11 (Tie)
    The Benders - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)
    Shadow - Eliminated Round 13 - #4
    Hell House - Eliminated Round 9 (Tie)
    Something Wicked - Eliminated Round 11 (Tie)
    Provenance - Eliminated Round 4
    Dead Man's Blood - Eliminated Round 10 (Tie)
    Salvation - Eliminated Round 12 - #5
    Devil's Trap - BEST S1 EPISODE

    Season 2
    In My Time of Dying - BEST S2 EPISODE
    Everybody Loves a Clown - Eliminated Round 5
    Bloodlust - Eliminated Round 7 (Tie)
    Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things - Eliminated Round 14
    Simon Said - Eliminated Round 7 (Tie)
    No Exit - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    The Usual Suspects - Eliminated Round 2 (Tie)
    Crossroad Blues - Eliminated Round 8
    Croatoan - Eliminated Round 4
    Hunted - Eliminated Round 12
    Playthings - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    Nightshifter - Eliminated Round 15 - #5
    Houses of the Holy - Eliminated Round 11
    Born Under a Bad Sign - Eliminated Round 17 - #3
    Tall Tales - Eliminated Round 2 (Tie)
    Roadkill - Eliminated Round 10
    Heart - Eliminated Round 13
    Hollywood Babylon - Eliminated Round 3
    Folsom Prison Blues - Eliminated Round 6 (Tie)
    What Is and What Should Never Be - Eliminated Round 18 - #2
    All Hell Breaks Loose (Part I) - Eliminated Round 9
    All Hell Breaks Loose (Part II)- Eliminated Round 16 - #4

    Season 3
    The Magnificent Seven - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    The Kids Are Alright - Eliminated Round 6
    Bad Day at Black Rock - Eliminated Round 7 (Tie)
    Sin City - Eliminated Round 7 (Tie)
    Bedtime Stories - Eliminated Round 4 (Tie)
    Red Sky at Morning - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    Fresh Blood - Eliminated Round 10 - #3
    A Very Supernatural Christmas- Eliminated Round 11 - #2
    Malleus Maleficarum - Eliminated Round 3
    Dream a Little Dream of Me - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)
    Mystery Spot - Eliminated Round 8 - #5
    Jus in Bello - Eliminated Round 9 - #4

    Ghostfacers- Eliminated Round 4 (Tie)
    Long-Distance Call - Eliminated Round 2
    Time Is On My Side - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)
    No Rest for the Wicked - BEST S3 EPISODE

    Season 4
    Lazarus Rising - Eliminated Round 14 - #3
    Are You There God? It's Me, Dean Winchester - Eliminated Round 4
    In the Beginning - BEST SEASON 4 EPISODE
    Metamorphosis - Eliminated Round 9 (Tie)
    Monster Movie - Eliminated Round 6 (Tie)
    Yellow Fever - Eliminated Round 2 (Tie)
    It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester - Eliminated Round 13 - #4
    Wishful Thinking - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)
    I Know What You Did Last Summer - Eliminated Round 10
    Heaven and Hell - Eliminated Round 6 (Tie)
    Family Remains - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    Criss Angel is a Douchebag - Eliminated Round 3 (Tie)
    After School Special - Eliminated Round 8
    Sex and Violence - Eliminated Round 2 (Tie)
    Death Takes a Holiday - Eliminated Round 12 - #5
    On the Head of a Pin - Eliminated Round 3 (Tie)
    It's a Terrible Life - Eliminated Round 11
    The Monster at the End of This Book - Eliminated Round 9 (Tie)
    Jump the Shark - Eliminated Round 7
    The Rapture - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    When the Levee Breaks - Eliminated Round 15 - #2
    Lucifer Rising - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)

    Season 5
    Sympathy for the Devil - Eliminated Round 6 (Tie)
    Good God, Y'all - Eliminated Round 10
    Free to Be You and Me - Eliminated Round 9
    The End - Eliminated Round 16 - # 2
    Fallen Idols - Eliminated Round 3
    I Believe the Children Are Our Future - Eliminated Round 2
    The Curious Case of Dean Winchester - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    Changing Channels - Eliminated Round 8 (Tie)
    The Real Ghostbusters - Eliminated Round 6 (Tie)
    Abandon All Hope - Eliminated Round 13 - # 5
    Sam, Interrupted - Eliminated Round 6 (Tie)
    Swap Meat - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    The Song Remains the Same - Elminated Round 15 - # 3
    My Bloody Valentine - Eliminated Round 8 (Tie)
    Dead Men Don't Wear Plaid - Eliminated Round 7
    Dark Side of the Moon - Eliminated Round 14 - # 4
    99 Problems- Eliminated Round 12
    Point of No Return - Eliminated Round 11 (Tie)
    Hammer of the Gods - Eliminated Round 5
    The Devil You Know - Eliminated Round 4
    Two Minutes to Midnight - Eliminated Round 11 (Tie)
    Swan Song - BEST SEASON 5 EPISODE

    Season 6
    Exile on Main St. - Eliminated Round 3
    Two and a Half Men - Eliminated Round 5
    The Third Man - Eliminated Round 6
    Weekend at Bobby's - BEST SEASON 6 EPISODE
    Live Free or TwiHard - Eliminated Round 15
    You Can't Handle the Truth - Eliminated Round 10
    Family Matters - Eliminated Round 7
    All Dogs Go to Heaven - Eliminated Round 2
    Clap Your Hands If You Believe - Eliminated Round 17 - # 5
    Caged Heat - Eliminated Round 1
    Appointment in Samarra - Eliminated Round 19 - # 3
    Like a Virgin - Eliminated Round 14
    Unforgiven - Eliminated Round 12
    Mannequin 3: The Reckoning - Eliminated Round 4
    The French Mistake - Eliminated Round 13
    And Then There Were None - Eliminated Round 9
    My Heart Will Go On - Eliminated Round 11
    Frontierland - Eliminated Round 18 - # 4
    Mommy Dearest - Eliminated Round 16
    The Man Who Would Be King - Eliminated Round 8
    Let It Bleed - Eliminated Round 19 - # 2
    The Man Who Knew Too Much - Eliminated Round 16

    Season 7
    Meet The New Boss - Eliminated Round 7
    Hello, Cruel World - Eliminated Round 18 - # 5
    The Girl Next Door - Eliminated Round 8
    Defending Your Life - Eliminated Round 12
    Shut-Up, Dr. Phil - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    Slash Fiction - Eliminated Round 16
    The Mentalists - Eliminated Round 15
    Time For A Wedding - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters - Eliminated Round 10
    Death's Door - Eliminated Round 20 - # 3
    Adventures In Babysitting - Eliminated Round 11
    Time After Time
    The Slice Girls - Eliminated Round 3
    Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie - Eliminated Round 14
    Repo Man - Eliminated Round 19 - # 4
    Out With The Old - Eliminated Round 5
    The Born-Again Identity - BEST SEASON 7 EPISODE
    Party On, Garth - Eliminated Round 9
    Of Grave Importance - Eliminated Round 13
    The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo - Eliminated Round 21 - #2
    Reading Is Fundamental - Eliminated Round 2
    There Will Be Blood - Eliminated Round 6
    Survival Of The Fittest - Eliminated Round 4

    ************************************************** ***********************

    Intermission

    Best of S1 - S7
    Devil's Trap - Eliminated Round 8
    Faith
    Scarecrow - Eliminated Round 4
    In My Time of Dying
    What Is and What Should Never Be
    Born Under A Bad Sign
    No Rest For The Wicked - Eliminated Round 9
    A Very Supernatural Christmas
    Fresh Blood
    In The Beginning
    When The Levee Breaks - Eliminated Round 7
    Lazarus Rising
    Swan Song
    The End
    The Song Remains The Same - Eliminated Round 6
    Weekend At Bobby's - Eliminated Round 2
    Let It Bleed - Eliminated Round 3 (Tie)
    Appointment In Samarra - Eliminated Round 5
    The Born-Again Identity - Eliminated Round 3 (Tie)
    The Girl With The Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo - Eliminated Round 1
    Death's Door - Eliminated Round 10

    ************************************************** ***********************

    Season 8
    We Need To Talk About Kevin
    What's Up, Tiger Mommy?
    Heartache
    Bitten
    Blood Brother
    Southern Comfort
    A Little Slice Of Kevin
    Hunteri Heroici
    Citizen Fang
    Torn and Frayed
    LARP and The Real Girl
    As Time Goes By
    Everybody Loves Hitler
    Trial and Error
    Man's Best Friend with Benefits
    Remember The Titans
    Goodbye Stranger
    Freaks and Geeks
    Taxi Driver
    Pac-Man Fever
    The Great Escapist
    Clip Show
    Sacrifice
    Last edited by galathea; 12-07-13, 10:26 AM.

  • #2
    The Best Supernatural Episode Tournament

    So, like I said in the character game, we are playing an Eppy tourney for SN now. We're going to be voting for our LEAST favorites again. And instead of pitting every single episode of SN against each other at once, we are going to do it by season, and then we shall let the winners of each season face each other, but that's not for awhile. We're starting by Season. So right now just vote for your LEAST FAVORITES FROM SEASON 1, and when we finish Season 1, we move to Season 2, etc. Get it?

    Season 1
    Pilot - Eliminated Round 7
    Wendigo - Eliminated Round 3 (Tie)
    Dead in the Water - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)
    Phantom Traveler - Eliminated Round 10 (Tie)
    Bloody Mary - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)
    Skin - Eliminated Round 6
    Hook Man - Eliminated Round 1
    Bugs - Eliminated Round 2
    Home - Eliminated Round 8
    Asylum - Eliminated Round 9 (Tie)
    Scarecrow - Eliminated Round 14 - #3
    Faith - Eliminated Round 15 - #2
    Route 666 - Eliminated Round 3 (Tie)
    Nightmare - Eliminated Round 11 (Tie)
    The Benders - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)
    Shadow - Eliminated Round 13 - #4
    Hell House - Eliminated Round 9 (Tie)
    Something Wicked - Eliminated Round 11 (Tie)
    Provenance - Eliminated Round 4
    Dead Man's Blood - Eliminated Round 10 (Tie)
    Salvation - Eliminated Round 12 - #5
    Devil's Trap - BEST S1 EPISODE

    Season 2
    In My Time of Dying - BEST S2 EPISODE

    Everybody Loves a Clown - Eliminated Round 5
    Bloodlust - Eliminated Round 7 (Tie)
    Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things - Eliminated Round 14
    Simon Said - Eliminated Round 7 (Tie)
    No Exit - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    The Usual Suspects - Eliminated Round 2 (Tie)
    Crossroad Blues - Eliminated Round 8
    Croatoan - Eliminated Round 4
    Hunted - Eliminated Round 12
    Playthings - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    Nightshifter - Eliminated Round 15 - #5
    Houses of the Holy - Eliminated Round 11
    Born Under a Bad Sign - Eliminated Round 17 - #3
    Tall Tales - Eliminated Round 2 (Tie)
    Roadkill - Eliminated Round 10
    Heart - Eliminated Round 13
    Hollywood Babylon - Eliminated Round 3
    Folsom Prison Blues - Eliminated Round 6 (Tie)
    What Is and What Should Never Be - Eliminated Round 18 - #2
    All Hell Breaks Loose (Part I) - Eliminated Round 9
    All Hell Breaks Loose (Part II)- Eliminated Round 16 - #4

    Season 3
    The Magnificent Seven - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    The Kids Are Alright - Eliminated Round 6
    Bad Day at Black Rock - Eliminated Round 7 (Tie)
    Sin City - Eliminated Round 7 (Tie)
    Bedtime Stories - Eliminated Round 4 (Tie)
    Red Sky at Morning - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    Fresh Blood - Eliminated Round 10 - #3
    A Very Supernatural Christmas- Eliminated Round 11 - #2
    Malleus Maleficarum - Eliminated Round 3
    Dream a Little Dream of Me - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)
    Mystery Spot - Eliminated Round 8 - #5
    Jus in Bello - Eliminated Round 9 - #4
    Ghostfacers- Eliminated Round 4 (Tie)
    Long-Distance Call - Eliminated Round 2
    Time Is On My Side - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)
    No Rest for the Wicked - BEST S3 EPISODE

    Season 4
    Lazarus Rising - Eliminated Round 14 - #3
    Are You There God? It's Me, Dean Winchester - Eliminated Round 4
    In the Beginning - BEST SEASON 4 EPISODE
    Metamorphosis - Eliminated Round 9 (Tie)
    Monster Movie - Eliminated Round 6 (Tie)
    Yellow Fever - Eliminated Round 2 (Tie)
    It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester - Eliminated Round 13 - #4
    Wishful Thinking - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)
    I Know What You Did Last Summer - Eliminated Round 10
    Heaven and Hell - Eliminated Round 6 (Tie)
    Family Remains - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    Criss Angel is a Douchebag - Eliminated Round 3 (Tie)
    After School Special - Eliminated Round 8
    Sex and Violence - Eliminated Round 2 (Tie)
    Death Takes a Holiday - Eliminated Round 12 - #5
    On the Head of a Pin - Eliminated Round 3 (Tie)
    It's a Terrible Life - Eliminated Round 11
    The Monster at the End of This Book - Eliminated Round 9 (Tie)
    Jump the Shark - Eliminated Round 7
    The Rapture - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    When the Levee Breaks - Eliminated Round 15 - #2
    Lucifer Rising - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)

    Season 5
    Sympathy for the Devil - Eliminated Round 6 (Tie)
    Good God, Y'all - Eliminated Round 10
    Free to Be You and Me - Eliminated Round 9
    The End - Eliminated Round 16 - # 2
    Fallen Idols - Eliminated Round 3
    I Believe the Children Are Our Future - Eliminated Round 2
    The Curious Case of Dean Winchester - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    Changing Channels - Eliminated Round 8 (Tie)
    The Real Ghostbusters - Eliminated Round 6 (Tie)
    Abandon All Hope... - Eliminated Round 13
    Sam, Interrupted - Eliminated Round 6 (Tie)
    Swap Meat - Eliminated Round 1 (Tie)
    The Song Remains the Same - Elminated Round 15
    My Bloody Valentine - Eliminated Round 8 (Tie)
    Dead Men Don't Wear Plaid - Eliminated Round 7
    Dark Side of the Moon - Eliminated Round 14
    99 Problems- Eliminated Round 12
    Point of No Return - Eliminated Round 11 (Tie)
    Hammer of the Gods - Eliminated Round 5
    The Devil You Know - Eliminated Round 4
    Two Minutes to Midnight - Eliminated Round 11 (Tie)
    Swan Song - BEST SEASON 5 EPISODE

    Season 6
    Exile on Main St. - Eliminated Round 3
    Two and a Half Men - Eliminated Round 5
    The Third Man - Eliminated Round 6
    Weekend at Bobby's
    Live Free or TwiHard - Eliminated Round 15
    You Can't Handle the Truth - Eliminated Round 10
    Family Matters - Eliminated Round 7
    All Dogs Go to Heaven - Eliminated Round 2
    Clap Your Hands If You Believe... - Eliminated Round 17
    Caged Heat - Eliminated Round 1
    Appointment in Samarra
    Like a Virgin - Eliminated Round 14
    Unforgiven - Eliminated Round 12
    Mannequin 3: The Reckoning - Eliminated Round 4
    The French Mistake - Eliminated Round 13
    ...And Then There Were None - Eliminated Round 9
    My Heart Will Go On - Eliminated Round 11
    Frontierland - Eliminated Round 18
    Mommy Dearest - Eliminated Round 16
    The Man Who Would Be King - Eliminated Round 8
    Let It Bleed
    The Man Who Knew Too Much - Eliminated Round 16

    Vote for your FIVE least favorite episodes now.
    Last edited by BlasterBoy; 13-05-11, 09:00 PM.

    Comment


    • #3
      Wendigo
      Hook Man
      Bugs
      Route 666
      Provenance

      Comment


      • #4
        Okay then, here we go!

        Bugs
        Hook Man
        Route 666
        Asylum (sorry, it's the only episode I have ever wanted to just STOP watching! )
        Dead Man's Blood (I'm not a big vampire fan when it comes to SN... )
        Promise that you'll return to me.

        icon by sireesanswar

        Comment


        • #5
          Wendigo
          Skin
          Hook Man
          Bugs
          Provenance

          Comment


          • #6
            Route 666
            Hook Man
            Wendigo
            Provenance
            Home

            Comment


            • #7
              Wendigo
              Bugs
              Hook Man
              Route 666
              Asylum
              sigpic

              http://buffysmom.wordpress.com/

              Comment


              • #8
                Wendigo
                Hook Man
                Bugs
                Asylum
                Route 666

                Comment


                • #9
                  Sherr, I will never understand your hate for "Asylum"

                  Round 1:

                  Hook Man - 6
                  Wendigo - 5
                  Bugs - 5
                  Route 666 - 5
                  Provenance - 3
                  Asylum - 3
                  Dead Man's Blood - 1
                  Skin - 1
                  Home - 1

                  Hook Man is eliminated for Round 1.

                  Vote for five.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Wendigo
                    Something Wicked
                    Bugs
                    Route 666
                    Provenance

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Sherr, I will never understand your hate for "Asylum"
                      I can, it's sleep inducing.

                      This is already getting hard, I love Season 1 too much!

                      Wendigo
                      Bloody Mary
                      Bugs
                      Asylum
                      Route 666

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by BlasterBoy View Post
                        Sherr, I will never understand your hate for "Asylum"
                        Right there with you. I am amazed that Asylum got 3 (!) votes.

                        Originally posted by BlasterBoy View Post
                        Wendigo
                        Something Wicked
                        Bugs
                        Route 666
                        Provenance
                        You vote for Something Wicked?!?!?!?! This is like one of the most important episodes in S1. It's one of my absolute favourites.

                        Route 666
                        Wendigo
                        Provenance
                        Home
                        Bugs

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by galathea View Post
                          You vote for Something Wicked?!?!?!?! This is like one of the most important episodes in S1. It's one of my absolute favourites.
                          Well, you're voting for Home! But seriously, with Something Wicked, I cannot remember that episode almost at all, it left almost no impression on me so it was between that and Bloody Mary/Hell House, but I actually remember those two episodes....:-/

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by BlasterBoy View Post
                            Sherr, I will never understand your hate for "Asylum"
                            Dude, I could not BEAR it, okay?! I hated nearly every minute there were in that Asylum, I felt trapped and terrified and overly stressed and tense, and wanted out, wanted to stop watching, I barely finished! I cannot even imagine rewatching it, besides a few select scenes perhaps! So NOW can you understand why I hate this episode?!

                            Bugs
                            Provenance
                            Route 666
                            Asylum
                            Dead Man's Blood
                            Promise that you'll return to me.

                            icon by sireesanswar

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by BlasterBoy View Post
                              Well, you're voting for Home! But seriously, with Something Wicked, I cannot remember that episode almost at all, it left almost no impression on me so it was between that and Bloody Mary/Hell House, but I actually remember those two episodes....:-/
                              The first flashbacks to Sam and Dean's childhood! How can you not remember that? It was the key to the understanding of Dean's character and his relationship with Sam for me.

                              I simply vote for Home because I hate Missouri with fiery passion and she is too prominently featured in the episode to just make me forget that she's there. Love the storyline of the boys though.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X