Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Ats Best Episodes - number edition

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • - WWF
    + Salvage

    Waiting in the Wings - 5
    Salvage - 7
    Why We Fight - 4

    Reset at:
    3

    Eliminated:
    3.
    4. Happy Anniversary
    5. She

    Results:
    Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
    Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
    Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
    Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
    Winner of Episode 6: Billy
    Winner of Episode 7: Darla
    Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
    Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
    Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
    Winner of Episode 11: Damage
    Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
    Winner of Episode 13:
    Winner of Episode 14:
    Winner of Episode 15:
    Winner of Episode 16:
    Winner of Episode 17:
    Winner of Episode 18:
    Winner of Episode 20:
    Winner of Episode 21:
    Winner of Episode 22:

    Comment


    • - WWF
      + WitW

      Waiting in the Wings - 6
      Salvage - 7
      Why We Fight - 3

      Reset at:
      3

      Eliminated:
      3.
      4. Happy Anniversary
      5. She

      Results:
      Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
      Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
      Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
      Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
      Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
      Winner of Episode 6: Billy
      Winner of Episode 7: Darla
      Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
      Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
      Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
      Winner of Episode 11: Damage
      Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
      Winner of Episode 13:
      Winner of Episode 14:
      Winner of Episode 15:
      Winner of Episode 16:
      Winner of Episode 17:
      Winner of Episode 18:
      Winner of Episode 20:
      Winner of Episode 21:
      Winner of Episode 22:

      You keep waiting for the dust to settle and then you realize it; the dust is your life going on. If happy comes along - that weird unbearable delight that's actual happy - I think you have to grab it while you can. You take what you can get, 'cause it's here, and then...gone.

      Comment


      • - WWF
        + WitW

        Waiting in the Wings - 7
        Salvage - 7
        Why We Fight - 2

        Reset at:
        3

        Eliminated:
        3.
        4. Happy Anniversary
        5. She

        Results:
        Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
        Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
        Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
        Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
        Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
        Winner of Episode 6: Billy
        Winner of Episode 7: Darla
        Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
        Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
        Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
        Winner of Episode 11: Damage
        Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
        Winner of Episode 13:
        Winner of Episode 14:
        Winner of Episode 15:
        Winner of Episode 16:
        Winner of Episode 17:
        Winner of Episode 18:
        Winner of Episode 20:
        Winner of Episode 21:
        Winner of Episode 22:


        Can we agree that the writers made everyone do and say everything with a thought to getting good ratings and being renewed. This includes everything we love as well as everything we hate.

        Comment


        • - WWF
          + Salvage

          Waiting in the Wings - 7
          Salvage - 8
          Why We Fight - 1

          Reset at:
          3

          Eliminated:
          3.
          4. Happy Anniversary
          5. She

          Results:
          Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
          Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
          Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
          Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
          Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
          Winner of Episode 6: Billy
          Winner of Episode 7: Darla
          Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
          Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
          Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
          Winner of Episode 11: Damage
          Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
          Winner of Episode 13:
          Winner of Episode 14:
          Winner of Episode 15:
          Winner of Episode 16:
          Winner of Episode 17:
          Winner of Episode 18:
          Winner of Episode 20:
          Winner of Episode 21:
          Winner of Episode 22:

          Comment


          • I think Waiting in the Wings is probably objectively the much stronger and cohesive episode overall. Although, it has a plot of plot elements that I personally am not a fan of (Wes/Fred/Gunn and Angel/Cordy) whereas whilst Savage isn't as structurally tight I love Faith's appearance and the Wes/Lilah scenes. Honestly, WitW should probably really win but I'll vote with my personal preferences for now.

            - WWF (Eliminated)
            + Salvage

            Waiting in the Wings - 7
            Salvage - 9


            Reset at:
            3

            Eliminated:
            3. Why We Fight
            4. Happy Anniversary
            5. She

            Results:
            Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
            Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
            Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
            Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
            Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
            Winner of Episode 6: Billy
            Winner of Episode 7: Darla
            Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
            Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
            Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
            Winner of Episode 11: Damage
            Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
            Winner of Episode 13:
            Winner of Episode 14:
            Winner of Episode 15:
            Winner of Episode 16:
            Winner of Episode 17:
            Winner of Episode 18:
            Winner of Episode 20:
            Winner of Episode 21:
            Winner of Episode 22:

            "The earth is doomed!" - Banner by Nina

            Comment


            • + Salvage
              - WitW

              Waiting in the Wings - 6
              Salvage - 10


              Reset at:
              3

              Eliminated:
              3. Why We Fight
              4. Happy Anniversary
              5. She

              Results:
              Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
              Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
              Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
              Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
              Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
              Winner of Episode 6: Billy
              Winner of Episode 7: Darla
              Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
              Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
              Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
              Winner of Episode 11: Damage
              Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
              Winner of Episode 13:
              Winner of Episode 14:
              Winner of Episode 15:
              Winner of Episode 16:
              Winner of Episode 17:
              Winner of Episode 18:
              Winner of Episode 20:
              Winner of Episode 21:
              Winner of Episode 22:

              Comment


              • I'm very torn between these and would be very happy with either. WitW is a favourite and I know I've chosen it above Salvage before. But it is always going to be a close call that could tip either way and having seen it just recently, the excellence of that Wes/Lilah scene and how great Faith's return is are pipping WitW this time. I could definitely go the other way on another occasion.

                + Salvage
                - WitW

                Waiting in the Wings - 5
                Salvage - 11


                Reset at:
                3

                Eliminated:
                3. Why We Fight
                4. Happy Anniversary
                5. She

                Results:
                Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
                Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
                Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
                Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
                Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
                Winner of Episode 6: Billy
                Winner of Episode 7: Darla
                Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
                Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
                Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
                Winner of Episode 11: Damage
                Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
                Winner of Episode 13:
                Winner of Episode 14:
                Winner of Episode 15:
                Winner of Episode 16:
                Winner of Episode 17:
                Winner of Episode 18:
                Winner of Episode 20:
                Winner of Episode 21:
                Winner of Episode 22:

                Comment


                • What she said!

                  + Salvage
                  - WitW

                  Waiting in the Wings - 4
                  Salvage - 12


                  Reset at:
                  3

                  Eliminated:
                  3. Why We Fight
                  4. Happy Anniversary
                  5. She

                  Results:
                  Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
                  Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
                  Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
                  Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
                  Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
                  Winner of Episode 6: Billy
                  Winner of Episode 7: Darla
                  Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
                  Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
                  Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
                  Winner of Episode 11: Damage
                  Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
                  Winner of Episode 13:
                  Winner of Episode 14:
                  Winner of Episode 15:
                  Winner of Episode 16:
                  Winner of Episode 17:
                  Winner of Episode 18:
                  Winner of Episode 20:
                  Winner of Episode 21:
                  Winner of Episode 22:[/QUOTE]

                  Can we agree that the writers made everyone do and say everything with a thought to getting good ratings and being renewed. This includes everything we love as well as everything we hate.

                  Comment




                  • + Salvage
                    - WitW

                    Waiting in the Wings - 3
                    Salvage - 13


                    Reset at:
                    3

                    Eliminated:
                    3. Why We Fight
                    4. Happy Anniversary
                    5. She

                    Results:
                    Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
                    Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
                    Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
                    Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
                    Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
                    Winner of Episode 6: Billy
                    Winner of Episode 7: Darla
                    Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
                    Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
                    Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
                    Winner of Episode 11: Damage
                    Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
                    Winner of Episode 13:
                    Winner of Episode 14:
                    Winner of Episode 15:
                    Winner of Episode 16:
                    Winner of Episode 17:
                    Winner of Episode 18:
                    Winner of Episode 20:
                    Winner of Episode 21:
                    Winner of Episode 22:
                    "The earth is doomed!" - Banner by Nina

                    Comment


                    • + Salvage
                      - WitW

                      Waiting in the Wings - 2
                      Salvage - 14


                      Reset at:
                      3

                      Eliminated:
                      3. Why We Fight
                      4. Happy Anniversary
                      5. She

                      Results:
                      Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
                      Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
                      Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
                      Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
                      Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
                      Winner of Episode 6: Billy
                      Winner of Episode 7: Darla
                      Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
                      Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
                      Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
                      Winner of Episode 11: Damage
                      Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
                      Winner of Episode 13:
                      Winner of Episode 14:
                      Winner of Episode 15:
                      Winner of Episode 16:
                      Winner of Episode 17:
                      Winner of Episode 18:
                      Winner of Episode 20:
                      Winner of Episode 21:
                      Winner of Episode 22:

                      Comment


                      • + Salvage
                        - WitW

                        Waiting in the Wings - 1
                        Salvage - 15


                        Reset at:
                        3

                        Eliminated:
                        3. Why We Fight
                        4. Happy Anniversary
                        5. She

                        Results:
                        Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
                        Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
                        Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
                        Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
                        Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
                        Winner of Episode 6: Billy
                        Winner of Episode 7: Darla
                        Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
                        Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
                        Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
                        Winner of Episode 11: Damage
                        Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
                        Winner of Episode 13:
                        Winner of Episode 14:
                        Winner of Episode 15:
                        Winner of Episode 16:
                        Winner of Episode 17:
                        Winner of Episode 18:
                        Winner of Episode 20:
                        Winner of Episode 21:
                        Winner of Episode 22:

                        Comment


                        • + Salvage
                          - WitW

                          Waiting in the Wings - *wait over*
                          Salvage - 16


                          Reset at:
                          3

                          Eliminated:
                          2. Waiting in the Wings
                          3. Why We Fight
                          4. Happy Anniversary
                          5. She

                          Results:
                          Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
                          Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
                          Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
                          Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
                          Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
                          Winner of Episode 6: Billy
                          Winner of Episode 7: Darla
                          Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
                          Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
                          Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
                          Winner of Episode 11: Damage
                          Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
                          Winner of Episode 13: Salvage
                          Winner of Episode 14:
                          Winner of Episode 15:
                          Winner of Episode 16:
                          Winner of Episode 17:
                          Winner of Episode 18:
                          Winner of Episode 20:
                          Winner of Episode 21:
                          Winner of Episode 22:

                          Can we agree that the writers made everyone do and say everything with a thought to getting good ratings and being renewed. This includes everything we love as well as everything we hate.

                          Comment


                          • Onto round 14...

                            This is a pretty strong set. IGYUMS and "Couplet" are two underrated faves of mine. "Smile Time" is "Smile Time", and I have a soft spot for "The Thin Dead Line". My least favorite ep is probably Release, but I don't hate that one either.

                            + I've Got You Under My Skin
                            - Release

                            I've Got You Under My Skin - 6
                            The Thin Dead Line - 5
                            Couplet - 5
                            Release - 4
                            Smile Time - 5

                            Reset at:
                            3

                            Eliminated:
                            5.

                            Results:
                            Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
                            Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
                            Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
                            Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
                            Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
                            Winner of Episode 6: Billy
                            Winner of Episode 7: Darla
                            Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
                            Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
                            Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
                            Winner of Episode 11: Damage
                            Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
                            Winner of Episode 13: Salvage
                            Winner of Episode 14:
                            Winner of Episode 15:
                            Winner of Episode 16:
                            Winner of Episode 17:
                            Winner of Episode 18:
                            Winner of Episode 20:
                            Winner of Episode 21:
                            Winner of Episode 22:

                            Comment


                            • I don't hate Groo, but him being around for a whole episode is a bit much. So Couplet is the weakest link for me.


                              Smile Time +
                              Couplet -

                              I've Got You Under My Skin - 6
                              The Thin Dead Line - 5
                              Couplet - 4
                              Release - 4
                              Smile Time - 6

                              Reset at:
                              3

                              Eliminated:
                              5.

                              Results:
                              Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
                              Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
                              Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
                              Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
                              Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
                              Winner of Episode 6: Billy
                              Winner of Episode 7: Darla
                              Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
                              Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
                              Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
                              Winner of Episode 11: Damage
                              Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
                              Winner of Episode 13: Salvage
                              Winner of Episode 14:
                              Winner of Episode 15:
                              Winner of Episode 16:
                              Winner of Episode 17:
                              Winner of Episode 18:
                              Winner of Episode 20:
                              Winner of Episode 21:
                              Winner of Episode 22:

                              Comment


                              • It is a pretty strong group of episodes. Couplet has the start of Fred and Gunn, which is a relationship I don't really enjoy and which had quite a negative impact on the group so that takes more from the episodes positives for me than the others suffer.

                                Smile Time +
                                Couplet -

                                I've Got You Under My Skin - 6
                                The Thin Dead Line - 5
                                Couplet - 3
                                Release - 4
                                Smile Time - 7

                                Reset at:
                                3

                                Eliminated:
                                5.

                                Results:
                                Winner of Episode 1: Deep Down
                                Winner of Episode 2: Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
                                Winner of Episode 3: In The Dark
                                Winner of Episode 4: Hell Bound
                                Winner of Episode 5: Dear Boy
                                Winner of Episode 6: Billy
                                Winner of Episode 7: Darla
                                Winner of Episode 8: Destiny
                                Winner of Episode 9: Lullaby
                                Winner of Episode 10: Reunion
                                Winner of Episode 11: Damage
                                Winner of Episode 12: You're Welcome
                                Winner of Episode 13: Salvage
                                Winner of Episode 14:
                                Winner of Episode 15:
                                Winner of Episode 16:
                                Winner of Episode 17:
                                Winner of Episode 18:
                                Winner of Episode 20:
                                Winner of Episode 21:
                                Winner of Episode 22:

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X