Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

BtVS Best Episodes - number edition

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • + The Prom
    - Touched

    Go Fish - 4
    The Prom - 6
    The Yoko Factor - 5
    Spiral - 5
    Villains - 6
    Touched - 4

    Reset at:
    3

    Eliminated:
    06.

    Results:
    Winner of Episode 1: When She Was Bad
    Winner of Episode 2: Bargaining II
    Winner of Episode 3: School Hard
    Winner of Episode 4: Fear, Itself
    Winner of Episode 5: No Place Like Home
    Winner of Episode 6: The Pack
    Winner of Episode 7: Fool for Love
    Winner of Episode 8: Lovers Walk
    Winner of Episode 9: The Wish
    Winner of Episode 10: Hush
    Winner of Episode 11: Ted
    Winner of Episode 12: Helpless
    Winner of Episode 13: Dead Things
    Winner of Episode 14: Innocence
    Winner of Episode 15: Consequences
    Winner of Episode 16: The Body
    Winner of Episode 17: Passion
    Winner of Episode 18: Earshot
    Winner of Episode 20:
    Winner of Episode 21:
    Winner of Episode 22:

    Comment


    • Villains and The Prom really stand out to me in this batch I think. I'd probably go with either Touched or Spiral for the third space in the top three. I expected Touched to be the more marmite of the two and most likely it wouldn't hit top three anyway, but I'd like it to survive a bit longer.

      - Go Fish
      + Touched

      Go Fish - 3
      The Prom - 6
      The Yoko Factor - 5
      Spiral - 5
      Villains - 6
      Touched - 5

      Reset at:
      3

      Eliminated:
      06.

      Results:
      Winner of Episode 1: When She Was Bad
      Winner of Episode 2: Bargaining II
      Winner of Episode 3: School Hard
      Winner of Episode 4: Fear, Itself
      Winner of Episode 5: No Place Like Home
      Winner of Episode 6: The Pack
      Winner of Episode 7: Fool for Love
      Winner of Episode 8: Lovers Walk
      Winner of Episode 9: The Wish
      Winner of Episode 10: Hush
      Winner of Episode 11: Ted
      Winner of Episode 12: Helpless
      Winner of Episode 13: Dead Things
      Winner of Episode 14: Innocence
      Winner of Episode 15: Consequences
      Winner of Episode 16: The Body
      Winner of Episode 17: Passion
      Winner of Episode 18: Earshot
      Winner of Episode 20:
      Winner of Episode 21:
      Winner of Episode 22:

      Comment


      • bespangeled
        bespangeled commented
        Editing a comment
        Did I manage to miss Empty Places? I don't see it on the last list.

    • I think we might have skipped some episodes. Touched comes after Empty Places, but we went from Dirty Girls to Touched.
      Can we agree that the writers made everyone do and say everything with a thought to getting good ratings and being renewed. This includes everything we love as well as everything we hate.

      Comment


      • Originally posted by bespangeled View Post
        I think we might have skipped some episodes. Touched comes after Empty Places, but we went from Dirty Girls to Touched.
        Ha, you're right! We've totally missed out the 19th eps round. We could just finish up the 20th and then drop back to the 19th or halt this and restart on the 19th as we've only just started. I really don't mind which. The current eps should be...

        I Only Have Eyes For You
        Choices
        New Moon Rising
        Tough Love
        Seeing Red
        Empty Places

        Comment


        • I say we go back to the 19th and go in the proper order. I know we had a couple of votes but it makes sense to do it in a linear fashion, IMO. If people disagree feel free to chime in but if not I'll just get the ball rolling so that the game can pick up some momentum;

          + IOHEFY
          - Empty Places

          I Only Have Eyes For You - 6
          Choices - 5
          New Moon Rising -5
          Tough Love - 5
          Seeing Red - 5
          Empty Places -4

          Reset at:
          3

          Eliminated:
          06.

          Results:
          Winner of Episode 1: When She Was Bad
          Winner of Episode 2: Bargaining II
          Winner of Episode 3: School Hard
          Winner of Episode 4: Fear, Itself
          Winner of Episode 5: No Place Like Home
          Winner of Episode 6: The Pack
          Winner of Episode 7: Fool for Love
          Winner of Episode 8: Lovers Walk
          Winner of Episode 9: The Wish
          Winner of Episode 10: Hush
          Winner of Episode 11: Ted
          Winner of Episode 12: Helpless
          Winner of Episode 13: Dead Things
          Winner of Episode 14: Innocence
          Winner of Episode 15: Consequences
          Winner of Episode 16: The Body
          Winner of Episode 17: Passion
          Winner of Episode 18: Earshot
          Winner of Episode 19:
          Winner of Episode 20:
          Winner of Episode 21:
          Winner of Episode 22:

          ~ Banner by Nina ~

          Comment


          • I'm happy to drop back to the 19th eps first.

            Seeing Red, Choices and Tough Love would be my top three, in that order, but I expect IOHEFY to be a strong contender to win going by its popularity. I have come to appreciate it more over the years after hearing people's positive responses to it and can see the argument it should be top three over Tough Love. But it wouldn't beat the other two still for me. Objectively though, I can understand why it'll be a contender to win.

            + Seeing Red
            - New Moon Rising

            I Only Have Eyes For You - 6
            Choices - 5
            New Moon Rising - 4
            Tough Love - 5
            Seeing Red - 6
            Empty Places -4

            Reset at:
            3

            Eliminated:
            06.

            Results:
            Winner of Episode 1: When She Was Bad
            Winner of Episode 2: Bargaining II
            Winner of Episode 3: School Hard
            Winner of Episode 4: Fear, Itself
            Winner of Episode 5: No Place Like Home
            Winner of Episode 6: The Pack
            Winner of Episode 7: Fool for Love
            Winner of Episode 8: Lovers Walk
            Winner of Episode 9: The Wish
            Winner of Episode 10: Hush
            Winner of Episode 11: Ted
            Winner of Episode 12: Helpless
            Winner of Episode 13: Dead Things
            Winner of Episode 14: Innocence
            Winner of Episode 15: Consequences
            Winner of Episode 16: The Body
            Winner of Episode 17: Passion
            Winner of Episode 18: Earshot
            Winner of Episode 19:
            Winner of Episode 20:
            Winner of Episode 21:
            Winner of Episode 22:

            Comment


            • + IOHEFY
              - Empty Places

              I Only Have Eyes For You - 7
              Choices - 5
              New Moon Rising - 4
              Tough Love - 5
              Seeing Red - 6
              Empty Places -3

              Reset at:
              3

              Eliminated:
              06.

              Results:
              Winner of Episode 1: When She Was Bad
              Winner of Episode 2: Bargaining II
              Winner of Episode 3: School Hard
              Winner of Episode 4: Fear, Itself
              Winner of Episode 5: No Place Like Home
              Winner of Episode 6: The Pack
              Winner of Episode 7: Fool for Love
              Winner of Episode 8: Lovers Walk
              Winner of Episode 9: The Wish
              Winner of Episode 10: Hush
              Winner of Episode 11: Ted
              Winner of Episode 12: Helpless
              Winner of Episode 13: Dead Things
              Winner of Episode 14: Innocence
              Winner of Episode 15: Consequences
              Winner of Episode 16: The Body
              Winner of Episode 17: Passion
              Winner of Episode 18: Earshot
              Winner of Episode 19:
              Winner of Episode 20:
              Winner of Episode 21:
              Winner of Episode 22:

              Comment


              • Oh crap...how did I miss the fact "19" was missing?
                This is a good round, IOHEFY is one of my favorite episodes, and I love NMW and Seeing Red, too.


                + IOHEFY
                - Empty Places

                I Only Have Eyes For You - 8
                Choices - 5
                New Moon Rising - 4
                Tough Love - 5
                Seeing Red - 6
                Empty Places - 2

                Reset at:
                3

                Eliminated:
                06.

                Results:
                Winner of Episode 1: When She Was Bad
                Winner of Episode 2: Bargaining II
                Winner of Episode 3: School Hard
                Winner of Episode 4: Fear, Itself
                Winner of Episode 5: No Place Like Home
                Winner of Episode 6: The Pack
                Winner of Episode 7: Fool for Love
                Winner of Episode 8: Lovers Walk
                Winner of Episode 9: The Wish
                Winner of Episode 10: Hush
                Winner of Episode 11: Ted
                Winner of Episode 12: Helpless
                Winner of Episode 13: Dead Things
                Winner of Episode 14: Innocence
                Winner of Episode 15: Consequences
                Winner of Episode 16: The Body
                Winner of Episode 17: Passion
                Winner of Episode 18: Earshot
                Winner of Episode 19:
                Winner of Episode 20:
                Winner of Episode 21:
                Winner of Episode 22:

                You keep waiting for the dust to settle and then you realize it; the dust is your life going on. If happy comes along - that weird unbearable delight that's actual happy - I think you have to grab it while you can. You take what you can get, 'cause it's here, and then...gone.

                Comment


                • I think I want IOHEFY you to win this one but I also have a massive soft spot for New Moon Rising. Honestly, I'm lukewarm on both Choices and Tough Love as a whole. I really like certain scenes in both but am not blown away by either episode, either.

                  Seeing Red I'm not overly fond of to. Cutting to an ad break during the AR scene is one of the worst choices I think the series ever made frankly. I think it's certainly an episode where a lot happens in it but I don't think that equates to it being a particularly great episode though.

                  + New Moon Rising
                  - Empty Places

                  I Only Have Eyes For You - 9
                  Choices - 5
                  New Moon Rising - 5
                  Tough Love - 5
                  Seeing Red - 6
                  Empty Places - 1

                  Reset at:
                  3

                  Eliminated:
                  06.

                  Results:
                  Winner of Episode 1: When She Was Bad
                  Winner of Episode 2: Bargaining II
                  Winner of Episode 3: School Hard
                  Winner of Episode 4: Fear, Itself
                  Winner of Episode 5: No Place Like Home
                  Winner of Episode 6: The Pack
                  Winner of Episode 7: Fool for Love
                  Winner of Episode 8: Lovers Walk
                  Winner of Episode 9: The Wish
                  Winner of Episode 10: Hush
                  Winner of Episode 11: Ted
                  Winner of Episode 12: Helpless
                  Winner of Episode 13: Dead Things
                  Winner of Episode 14: Innocence
                  Winner of Episode 15: Consequences
                  Winner of Episode 16: The Body
                  Winner of Episode 17: Passion
                  Winner of Episode 18: Earshot
                  Winner of Episode 19:
                  Winner of Episode 20:
                  Winner of Episode 21:
                  Winner of Episode 22:


                  ~ Banner by Nina ~

                  Comment


                  • Has everyone forgotten about the game?
                    I think it's been two days.

                    + Seeing Red (I actually think the episode is very well written and acted and this is often overlooked because of how controversial the events in it are)
                    - Empty Places *abandoned*

                    I Only Have Eyes For You - 9
                    Choices - 5
                    New Moon Rising - 5
                    Tough Love - 5
                    Seeing Red - 7


                    Reset at:
                    3

                    Eliminated:
                    05.
                    06. Empty Places

                    Results:
                    Winner of Episode 1: When She Was Bad
                    Winner of Episode 2: Bargaining II
                    Winner of Episode 3: School Hard
                    Winner of Episode 4: Fear, Itself
                    Winner of Episode 5: No Place Like Home
                    Winner of Episode 6: The Pack
                    Winner of Episode 7: Fool for Love
                    Winner of Episode 8: Lovers Walk
                    Winner of Episode 9: The Wish
                    Winner of Episode 10: Hush
                    Winner of Episode 11: Ted
                    Winner of Episode 12: Helpless
                    Winner of Episode 13: Dead Things
                    Winner of Episode 14: Innocence
                    Winner of Episode 15: Consequences
                    Winner of Episode 16: The Body
                    Winner of Episode 17: Passion
                    Winner of Episode 18: Earshot
                    Winner of Episode 19:
                    Winner of Episode 20:
                    Winner of Episode 21:
                    Winner of Episode 22:


                    You keep waiting for the dust to settle and then you realize it; the dust is your life going on. If happy comes along - that weird unbearable delight that's actual happy - I think you have to grab it while you can. You take what you can get, 'cause it's here, and then...gone.

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by TimeTravellingBunny View Post
                      Has everyone forgotten about the game?
                      Sorry my bad, I thought I couldn't go yet but should have checked when noone else was posting. Agreed on Seeing Red.

                      + Seeing Red
                      - New Moon Rising

                      I Only Have Eyes For You - 9
                      Choices - 5
                      New Moon Rising - 4
                      Tough Love - 5
                      Seeing Red - 8


                      Reset at:
                      3

                      Eliminated:
                      05.
                      06. Empty Places

                      Results:
                      Winner of Episode 1: When She Was Bad
                      Winner of Episode 2: Bargaining II
                      Winner of Episode 3: School Hard
                      Winner of Episode 4: Fear, Itself
                      Winner of Episode 5: No Place Like Home
                      Winner of Episode 6: The Pack
                      Winner of Episode 7: Fool for Love
                      Winner of Episode 8: Lovers Walk
                      Winner of Episode 9: The Wish
                      Winner of Episode 10: Hush
                      Winner of Episode 11: Ted
                      Winner of Episode 12: Helpless
                      Winner of Episode 13: Dead Things
                      Winner of Episode 14: Innocence
                      Winner of Episode 15: Consequences
                      Winner of Episode 16: The Body
                      Winner of Episode 17: Passion
                      Winner of Episode 18: Earshot
                      Winner of Episode 19:
                      Winner of Episode 20:
                      Winner of Episode 21:
                      Winner of Episode 22:

                      Comment


                      • TimeTravellingBunny
                        TimeTravellingBunny commented
                        Editing a comment
                        The Angel game is also stuck.

                      • Stoney
                        Stoney commented
                        Editing a comment
                        Sorry, probably me again, I'll go look.

                    • Can't say I've very strong feelings about any of these episodes, although IOHEFY is the best one I think.




                      + IOHEFY
                      - Tough Love

                      I Only Have Eyes For You - 10
                      Choices - 5
                      New Moon Rising - 4
                      Tough Love - 4
                      Seeing Red - 8


                      Reset at:
                      3

                      Eliminated:
                      05.
                      06. Empty Places

                      Results:
                      Winner of Episode 1: When She Was Bad
                      Winner of Episode 2: Bargaining II
                      Winner of Episode 3: School Hard
                      Winner of Episode 4: Fear, Itself
                      Winner of Episode 5: No Place Like Home
                      Winner of Episode 6: The Pack
                      Winner of Episode 7: Fool for Love
                      Winner of Episode 8: Lovers Walk
                      Winner of Episode 9: The Wish
                      Winner of Episode 10: Hush
                      Winner of Episode 11: Ted
                      Winner of Episode 12: Helpless
                      Winner of Episode 13: Dead Things
                      Winner of Episode 14: Innocence
                      Winner of Episode 15: Consequences
                      Winner of Episode 16: The Body
                      Winner of Episode 17: Passion
                      Winner of Episode 18: Earshot
                      Winner of Episode 19:
                      Winner of Episode 20:
                      Winner of Episode 21:
                      Winner of Episode 22:

                      Comment


                      • apologies:

                        have not forgotten—

                        just vicious migraine....


                        + Seeing Red
                        - Tough Love

                        I Only Have Eyes For You - 10
                        Choices - 5
                        New Moon Rising - 4
                        Tough Love - 3
                        Seeing Red - 9


                        Reset at:
                        3

                        Eliminated:
                        05.
                        06. Empty Places

                        Results:
                        Winner of Episode 1: When She Was Bad
                        Winner of Episode 2: Bargaining II
                        Winner of Episode 3: School Hard
                        Winner of Episode 4: Fear, Itself
                        Winner of Episode 5: No Place Like Home
                        Winner of Episode 6: The Pack
                        Winner of Episode 7: Fool for Love
                        Winner of Episode 8: Lovers Walk
                        Winner of Episode 9: The Wish
                        Winner of Episode 10: Hush
                        Winner of Episode 11: Ted
                        Winner of Episode 12: Helpless
                        Winner of Episode 13: Dead Things
                        Winner of Episode 14: Innocence
                        Winner of Episode 15: Consequences
                        Winner of Episode 16: The Body
                        Winner of Episode 17: Passion
                        Winner of Episode 18: Earshot
                        Winner of Episode 19:
                        Winner of Episode 20:
                        Winner of Episode 21:
                        Winner of Episode 22:

                        Comment





                        • + IOHEFY
                          - Tough Love

                          I Only Have Eyes For You - 11
                          Choices - 5
                          New Moon Rising - 4
                          Tough Love - 2
                          Seeing Red - 9


                          Reset at:
                          3

                          Eliminated:
                          05.
                          06. Empty Places

                          Results:
                          Winner of Episode 1: When She Was Bad
                          Winner of Episode 2: Bargaining II
                          Winner of Episode 3: School Hard
                          Winner of Episode 4: Fear, Itself
                          Winner of Episode 5: No Place Like Home
                          Winner of Episode 6: The Pack
                          Winner of Episode 7: Fool for Love
                          Winner of Episode 8: Lovers Walk
                          Winner of Episode 9: The Wish
                          Winner of Episode 10: Hush
                          Winner of Episode 11: Ted
                          Winner of Episode 12: Helpless
                          Winner of Episode 13: Dead Things
                          Winner of Episode 14: Innocence
                          Winner of Episode 15: Consequences
                          Winner of Episode 16: The Body
                          Winner of Episode 17: Passion
                          Winner of Episode 18: Earshot
                          Winner of Episode 19:
                          Winner of Episode 20:
                          Winner of Episode 21:
                          Winner of Episode 22:

                          ~ Banner by Nina ~

                          Comment


                          • + Seeing Red
                            - Tough Love

                            I Only Have Eyes For You - 11
                            Choices - 5
                            New Moon Rising - 4
                            Tough Love - 1
                            Seeing Red - 10


                            Reset at:
                            3

                            Eliminated:
                            05.
                            06. Empty Places

                            Results:
                            Winner of Episode 1: When She Was Bad
                            Winner of Episode 2: Bargaining II
                            Winner of Episode 3: School Hard
                            Winner of Episode 4: Fear, Itself
                            Winner of Episode 5: No Place Like Home
                            Winner of Episode 6: The Pack
                            Winner of Episode 7: Fool for Love
                            Winner of Episode 8: Lovers Walk
                            Winner of Episode 9: The Wish
                            Winner of Episode 10: Hush
                            Winner of Episode 11: Ted
                            Winner of Episode 12: Helpless
                            Winner of Episode 13: Dead Things
                            Winner of Episode 14: Innocence
                            Winner of Episode 15: Consequences
                            Winner of Episode 16: The Body
                            Winner of Episode 17: Passion
                            Winner of Episode 18: Earshot
                            Winner of Episode 19:
                            Winner of Episode 20:
                            Winner of Episode 21:
                            Winner of Episode 22:

                            Comment

                            Working...
                            X