Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

BtVS Episode Endings elimination game

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • + I Was Made To Love You
    - Innocence

    Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 3

    I Was Made to Love You : Buffy comes home to find her mother lying dead on the couch. - "Mommy?" - 6

    Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 7

    Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 10


    Reset at:
    5

    Eliminated:
    04.
    05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
    06. Restless
    07. I Robot, You Jane

    Results:
    Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
    Season 2 winner: Innocence
    Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
    Season 4 winner: Restless
    Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
    Season 6 winner: Smashed
    Season 7 winner: Beneath You
    Overall winner:

    Comment


    • - I Was Made To Love You
      + Beneath You

      Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 3

      I Was Made to Love You : Buffy comes home to find her mother lying dead on the couch. - "Mommy?" - 5

      Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 7

      Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 11


      Reset at:
      5

      Eliminated:
      04.
      05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
      06. Restless
      07. I Robot, You Jane

      Results:
      Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
      Season 2 winner: Innocence
      Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
      Season 4 winner: Restless
      Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
      Season 6 winner: Smashed
      Season 7 winner: Beneath You
      Overall winner:

      Comment


      • - Smashed
        + Innocence

        Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 4

        I Was Made to Love You : Buffy comes home to find her mother lying dead on the couch. - "Mommy?" - 5

        Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 6

        Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 11


        Reset at:
        5

        Eliminated:
        04.
        05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
        06. Restless
        07. I Robot, You Jane

        Results:
        Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
        Season 2 winner: Innocence
        Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
        Season 4 winner: Restless
        Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
        Season 6 winner: Smashed
        Season 7 winner: Beneath You
        Overall winner:

        Comment


        • Agreed, this is so difficult. Beneath You and Innocence are my top two, I'd be happy if either of them won. But they're all great, it's near impossible to vote against any.

          - IWMTLY
          + Beneath You

          Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 4

          I Was Made to Love You : Buffy comes home to find her mother lying dead on the couch. - "Mommy?" - 4

          Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 6

          Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 12


          Reset at:
          5

          Eliminated:
          04.
          05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
          06. Restless
          07. I Robot, You Jane

          Results:
          Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
          Season 2 winner: Innocence
          Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
          Season 4 winner: Restless
          Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
          Season 6 winner: Smashed
          Season 7 winner: Beneath You
          Overall winner:
          .
          .

          Comment


          • My top two are smashed and beneath you.


            - Innocence
            + smashed

            Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 3

            I Was Made to Love You : Buffy comes home to find her mother lying dead on the couch. - "Mommy?" - 4

            Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 7

            Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 12


            Reset at:
            5

            Eliminated:
            04.
            05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
            06. Restless
            07. I Robot, You Jane

            Results:
            Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
            Season 2 winner: Innocence
            Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
            Season 4 winner: Restless
            Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
            Season 6 winner: Smashed
            Season 7 winner: Beneath You
            Overall winner:[/QUOTE]


            “I like who I am when I’m with him. I like who we are together.”

            Comment


            • [QUOTE=GoSpuffy;753220]My top two are smashed and beneath you.


              - IWMTLY
              + Beneath You

              Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 3

              I Was Made to Love You : Buffy comes home to find her mother lying dead on the couch. - "Mommy?" - 3

              Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 7

              Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 13


              Reset at:
              5

              Eliminated:
              04.
              05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
              06. Restless
              07. I Robot, You Jane

              Results:
              Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
              Season 2 winner: Innocence
              Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
              Season 4 winner: Restless
              Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
              Season 6 winner: Smashed
              Season 7 winner: Beneath You
              Overall winner:

              Comment


              • + IWMTLY
                - Beneath You

                Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 3

                I Was Made to Love You : Buffy comes home to find her mother lying dead on the couch. - "Mommy?" - 4

                Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 7

                Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 12


                Reset at:
                5

                Eliminated:
                04.
                05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                06. Restless
                07. I Robot, You Jane

                Results:
                Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
                Season 2 winner: Innocence
                Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                Season 4 winner: Restless
                Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
                Season 6 winner: Smashed
                Season 7 winner: Beneath You
                Overall winner:

                Comment


                • I am most strongly drawn to Innocence and
                  Beneath You, followed closely by IWMTLY
                  to see any of them go will be most painful:

                  The first gathers all the complexities of Buffy's experience
                  in the early seasons so perfectly, while the second encapsulates
                  Spike's arc in the same way; the third, in its turn, in the break
                  in Buffy's voice, in her unanswered, questioning call, carries
                  so utterly the weight of her epochal loss...

                  This is not to say that I do not love Smashed... only
                  that it ranks well below the other three to me, especially
                  given that other endings of S6 were, in my view, finer...


                  + Innocence
                  - Smashed

                  Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 4

                  I Was Made to Love You : Buffy comes home to find her mother lying dead on the couch. - "Mommy?" - 4

                  Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 6

                  Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 12


                  Reset at:
                  5

                  Eliminated:
                  04.
                  05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                  06. Restless
                  07. I Robot, You Jane

                  Results:
                  Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
                  Season 2 winner: Innocence
                  Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                  Season 4 winner: Restless
                  Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
                  Season 6 winner: Smashed
                  Season 7 winner: Beneath You
                  Overall winner:
                  Last edited by StateOfSiege97; 12-09-19, 08:31 AM.

                  Comment


                  • + Beneath You
                    - IWMTLY

                    Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 4

                    I Was Made to Love You : Buffy comes home to find her mother lying dead on the couch. - "Mommy?" - 3

                    Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 6

                    Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 13


                    Reset at:
                    5

                    Eliminated:
                    04.
                    05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                    06. Restless
                    07. I Robot, You Jane

                    Results:
                    Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
                    Season 2 winner: Innocence
                    Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                    Season 4 winner: Restless
                    Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
                    Season 6 winner: Smashed
                    Season 7 winner: Beneath You
                    Overall winner:
                    You keep waiting for the dust to settle and then you realize it; the dust is your life going on. If happy comes along - that weird unbearable delight that's actual happy - I think you have to grab it while you can. You take what you can get, 'cause it's here, and then...gone.

                    Comment


                    • I do think Joyce's death is a hugely significant moment and appreciate that call out that can't be answered in a different way since you wrote so beautifully about it SoS. I would have chosen Innocence to go before it tbh but that was something that was being more fiercely blocked. And when there are such strong reasons for each episode like this it does of course become really a vote of personal preference. For me the complexity of the relationship dynamic between Buffy and Spike in S6 was incredibly compelling and the way they used both the action and text in that final scene of Smashed to expose the push/pull of the relationship as it took a step into a sexual dynamic was incredibly well done. But it is second to the exploration of Spike's character journey in BY for me.

                      + Beneath You
                      - IWMTLY

                      Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 4

                      I Was Made to Love You : Buffy comes home to find her mother lying dead on the couch. - "Mommy?" - 2

                      Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 6

                      Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 14


                      Reset at:
                      5

                      Eliminated:
                      04.
                      05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                      06. Restless
                      07. I Robot, You Jane

                      Results:
                      Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
                      Season 2 winner: Innocence
                      Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                      Season 4 winner: Restless
                      Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
                      Season 6 winner: Smashed
                      Season 7 winner: Beneath You
                      Overall winner:

                      Comment


                      • + Smashed
                        - innocence

                        Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 3

                        I Was Made to Love You : Buffy comes home to find her mother lying dead on the couch. - "Mommy?" - 2

                        Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 7

                        Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 14


                        Reset at:
                        5

                        Eliminated:
                        04.
                        05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                        06. Restless
                        07. I Robot, You Jane

                        Results:
                        Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
                        Season 2 winner: Innocence
                        Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                        Season 4 winner: Restless
                        Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
                        Season 6 winner: Smashed
                        Season 7 winner: Beneath You
                        Overall winner:[/QUOTE]


                        “I like who I am when I’m with him. I like who we are together.”

                        Comment


                        • -Smashed
                          + Innocence

                          Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 4

                          I Was Made to Love You : Buffy comes home to find her mother lying dead on the couch. - "Mommy?" - 2

                          Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 6

                          Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 14


                          Reset at:
                          5

                          Eliminated:
                          04.
                          05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                          06. Restless
                          07. I Robot, You Jane

                          Results:
                          Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
                          Season 2 winner: Innocence
                          Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                          Season 4 winner: Restless
                          Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
                          Season 6 winner: Smashed
                          Season 7 winner: Beneath You
                          Overall winner:

                          Comment


                          • + Beneath You
                            - IWMTLY

                            Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 4

                            I Was Made to Love You : Buffy comes home to find her mother lying dead on the couch. - "Mommy?" - 1

                            Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 6

                            Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 15


                            Reset at:
                            5

                            Eliminated:
                            04.
                            05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                            06. Restless
                            07. I Robot, You Jane

                            Results:
                            Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
                            Season 2 winner: Innocence
                            Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                            Season 4 winner: Restless
                            Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
                            Season 6 winner: Smashed
                            Season 7 winner: Beneath You
                            Overall winner:
                            You keep waiting for the dust to settle and then you realize it; the dust is your life going on. If happy comes along - that weird unbearable delight that's actual happy - I think you have to grab it while you can. You take what you can get, 'cause it's here, and then...gone.

                            Comment


                            • + Beneath You
                              - IWMTLY *dust*

                              Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 4

                              Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 6

                              Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 16


                              Reset at:
                              5

                              Eliminated:
                              03.
                              04. I Was Made to Love You
                              05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                              06. Restless
                              07. I Robot, You Jane

                              Results:
                              Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
                              Season 2 winner: Innocence
                              Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                              Season 4 winner: Restless
                              Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
                              Season 6 winner: Smashed
                              Season 7 winner: Beneath You
                              Overall winner:

                              Comment


                              • + Smashed
                                - Innocence

                                Innocence : "I'll just let it burn." - Buffy sits with Joyce seeking comfort as the candle in her birthday cupcake burns and the song in the movie finishes with "Remember that you're mine, sweetheart". - 3

                                Smashed : "You afraid I'm gonna-" - Buffy and Spike's fight becomes a passionate sexual encounter, as they fall through the floor together it ends with Buffy on top and the two staring into each other's eyes. - 7

                                Beneath You : "Buffy... can we rest?" - Having revealed that his soul has been restored, Buffy tearful looks on Spike's exhausted body hanging limply against the cross. - 16


                                Reset at:
                                5

                                Eliminated:
                                03.
                                04. I Was Made to Love You
                                05. Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                                06. Restless
                                07. I Robot, You Jane

                                Results:
                                Season 1 winner: I Robot, You Jane
                                Season 2 winner: Innocence
                                Season 3 winner: Graduation Day (Pt 1)
                                Season 4 winner: Restless
                                Season 5 winner: I Was Made to Love You
                                Season 6 winner: Smashed
                                Season 7 winner: Beneath You
                                Overall winner:[/QUOTE]


                                “I like who I am when I’m with him. I like who we are together.”

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X