Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

If you could recommend just one fanfic

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    Hard to pick just one. On the other hand there's not necessarily a ton I'd recommend at all. For Buffy I guess I'd go with Racing The Rain.

    Comment


    • #17
      I second DactylGirl's Lost Continent series. If there was one fanfic writer I'd recommend above all others, it would definitely be DactylGirl.

      I also liked Lizzrrbeathen's Adieu, A Dew, I Do, though I'd still place DactylGirl as more of a favourite. Also recommend TreacleA's No Mistakes. And though I only read this erratically (so couldn't join in discussion), I liked the Turn and Face the Strain series by Quinara.
      Last edited by SpuffyGlitz; 25-11-18, 07:31 PM.
      .
      .

      Comment


      • #18
        Hardly There:
        Pretty much all of them. Herself, Eury, even Shadow's. Among others. It's not the writing itself--if they were original fiction, I'd probably still like them--but the characters are still off.
        I`ve been thinking - because of your post - if it is even possible for a fanfic writer, to write any character "in character". If we assume - I do - that a character cannot be written OOC by the original author, because whatever they write is what they make of the character and therefore is in character?

        A fanfic writer on the other hand always has to take characters somewhere new, meaning somewhere, the original author did not take the character. And because they live through new experiences, they act or talk differently than we have seen them act or talk before.

        I love Herself. She is one of my favorite fanfic writers. But her fics are dark and the characters wallow on their own misery. This is something, we have seen in the show as well. But Herself focuses on it more than the show did and that makes her characters act and talk differently.

        Eurydices stories are well written, with lots of action, plot-twists, original characters, prophecies, demons, battles, spells - you hardly ever get a break. Now, we have seen quite a lot of plot twists, spells and demons in the show. But not as numerous as in Eurydices fics. Therefore her characters are bound to behave differently, than the ones we saw in the show. And they notably wallow less in their own misery than they did in the show. They don`t have time for that because there`s another plot twist waiting for them.

        Does shadow refer to shadowlass or to sabershadowkat or to someone else entirely?

        I re-read Gwennies A New Day, A New Dawn a short time ago. In her Story, Spike and Buffy have sex at the end of season 5, because of an "Aliens made them do it"- trope. I love this fic. It is so well written and I love her characters. But they are "off", simply because they never experienced the awkwardness of sex for other reasons than wanting to have great sex in the show and therefore we never saw them reacting to this situation and we will never know, how they would talk or act, if they found themselves in such a situation.

        flow
        ................................ Banner by buffylover

        Comment


        • #19
          Dunno, but I've read some fanfics where the writer pretty much got the characters (er some of the characters) right or kinda right. To be fair most don't, or rarely or only sometimes get them right.

          Comment


          • #20
            I’ve been lurking around this part of the forum for a while now - mainly looking for recs to be honest. I’ve read a lot of fan fiction so I’m up for anything.

            I’ve been wondering for a while why I never see Barb Cummings mentioned? She was the first author I ever got hooked on and it was her writing that made me like Buffy - Angearia and Lizarel had me loving her but Barb ‘showed’ her to me. So if I was recommending one only it would be Necessary Evils

            Barb also loves all the characters and could out-canon the most ardent fan ��

            Comment


            • #21
              I would suggest the Of Old Mystics by Wolfling and Ophalmos -- I've recommended it over and over. It is a Giles/Ethan pairing. The first I ever read, but it's about way more than just slash sex. It is so very complex and interesting -- about healing, about the mission of slaying and saving the world -- and yes, about the love between two very damaged people and how they come back to it. It was the first slash story that held my attention. Before this I was not a great fan of slash b/c I thought (and still think) too many of them are about 'love pwetty bwoys, let's make them #*@%' PWP is fine, it's just not that exciting to me at this stage in my life.

              This is hot, but it's way more than that -- and the 'boys' are grown men, even middle aged men, and I find that more interesting than the eyecandy #*@%-fics.

              It is now archived on AO3
              Of Old Mystics


              This not only made me want to read more slash, it also made me want to try my hand at seriously writing fan fiction. So I at least somewhat owe this fic my million plus words of fiction.

              Blue
              Last edited by DeepBlueJoy; 29-11-18, 01:42 PM.

              Comment


              • #22
                Originally posted by kamw30 View Post
                I’ve been lurking around this part of the forum for a while now - mainly looking for recs to be honest. I’ve read a lot of fan fiction so I’m up for anything.

                I’ve been wondering for a while why I never see Barb Cummings mentioned? She was the first author I ever got hooked on and it was her writing that made me like Buffy - Angearia and Lizarel had me loving her but Barb ‘showed’ her to me. So if I was recommending one only it would be Necessary Evils

                Barb also loves all the characters and could out-canon the most ardent fan ��
                I've read the prequel A Raising In The Sun a while back and really enjoyed it. I agree, Rahirah's skills are formidable; she writes all characters with great care, detail and fondness.

                Never got to Necessary Evils, though. It's on my reading list, although the formula and novel length keeps me procastrating. I think one day I'll get over myself.
                Last edited by Klaus Kartoffel; 29-11-18, 02:35 PM.

                Comment


                • #23
                  Originally posted by kamw30 View Post
                  I’ve been lurking around this part of the forum for a while now - mainly looking for recs to be honest. I’ve read a lot of fan fiction so I’m up for anything.

                  I’ve been wondering for a while why I never see Barb Cummings mentioned? She was the first author I ever got hooked on and it was her writing that made me like Buffy - Angearia and Lizarel had me loving her but Barb ‘showed’ her to me. So if I was recommending one only it would be Necessary Evils

                  Barb also loves all the characters and could out-canon the most ardent fan ��
                  Yes!! I haven't had time to reply to this thread yet (or any recent thread really) but my "one fanfic" recommendation would have been the entire Barbverse. Of course it would have been cheating a bit, because it is actually a large set of stories-- but since they all contribute to one big overarching story I would say it still counts.

                  https://archiveofourown.org/series/514
                  https://www.youtube.com/c/DoubleDutchess

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    Originally posted by flow View Post
                    Hardly There:

                    I`ve been thinking - because of your post - if it is even possible for a fanfic writer, to write any character "in character". If we assume - I do - that a character cannot be written OOC by the original author, because whatever they write is what they make of the character and therefore is in character?

                    A fanfic writer on the other hand always has to take characters somewhere new, meaning somewhere, the original author did not take the character. And because they live through new experiences, they act or talk differently than we have seen them act or talk before.

                    I love Herself. She is one of my favorite fanfic writers. But her fics are dark and the characters wallow on their own misery. This is something, we have seen in the show as well. But Herself focuses on it more than the show did and that makes her characters act and talk differently.

                    Eurydices stories are well written, with lots of action, plot-twists, original characters, prophecies, demons, battles, spells - you hardly ever get a break. Now, we have seen quite a lot of plot twists, spells and demons in the show. But not as numerous as in Eurydices fics. Therefore her characters are bound to behave differently, than the ones we saw in the show. And they notably wallow less in their own misery than they did in the show. They don`t have time for that because there`s another plot twist waiting for them.

                    Does shadow refer to shadowlass or to sabershadowkat or to someone else entirely?

                    I re-read Gwennies A New Day, A New Dawn a short time ago. In her Story, Spike and Buffy have sex at the end of season 5, because of an "Aliens made them do it"- trope. I love this fic. It is so well written and I love her characters. But they are "off", simply because they never experienced the awkwardness of sex for other reasons than wanting to have great sex in the show and therefore we never saw them reacting to this situation and we will never know, how they would talk or act, if they found themselves in such a situation.

                    flow
                    I think I've occasionally managed to do that accomplishment: writing a fanfic character *in character*, but you really do have to have a grasp of the individual fictional character's perspective; accents were lost in that, so it was far from perfect, but the attitudes were accurate.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X